Rich & Creamy Buttermilk Pie Recipe

If you’re on the hunt for a dessert that perfectly balances a smooth texture with a delicate tang, this Rich & Creamy Buttermilk Pie Recipe is about to become your new favorite. It’s a timeless Southern classic that brings together simple pantry ingredients into a luscious pie filling that’s just bursting with flavor. Every bite melts in your mouth, offering a creamy richness heightened by subtle notes of vanilla, lemon, and even a whisper of coconut. Whether you’re making it for a family gathering or just to treat yourself, this pie promises both comfort and elegance with minimal fuss.

Ingredients You’ll Need

These ingredients are beautifully straightforward but essential for capturing that perfect balance of creaminess, sweetness, and a slight tang in the pie. Each component plays a role in building the rich texture and luscious flavor we love in this dessert.

• 1½ cups granulated sugar: Sweetens the pie without overpowering the delicate buttermilk tang.
• ¼ cup all-purpose flour: Acts as a gentle thickener to give the filling its silky texture.
• ¼ teaspoon salt: Enhances all the flavors, making each element shine.
• 2 eggs, room temperature: Provide structure and richness for that creamy custard base.
• 1 egg yolk, room temperature: Adds extra silkiness and depth to the filling.
• 5 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted: Brings a luscious, velvety mouthfeel and subtle richness.
• 1½ teaspoons pure vanilla extract: Infuses warmth and classic flavor to brighten the pie.
• ¼ teaspoon lemon extract: Offers a fresh, citrusy lift that balances the sweetness perfectly.
• ⅛ teaspoon coconut extract: Adds subtle tropical notes that make this pie uniquely irresistible.
• 1 cup buttermilk, warm: The star ingredient that gives the pie its characteristic tang and creaminess.
• 1 (9-inch) unbaked pie shell, chilled: A crisp and tender base to cradle the luscious filling.

How to Make Rich & Creamy Buttermilk Pie Recipe

Step 1: Preheat Your Oven

Getting your oven ready at 350°F (175°C) is key to ensuring even baking. This temperature allows the pie to set gently without browning too quickly, giving you that perfect creamy texture that defines a great buttermilk pie.

Step 2: Combine the Dry Ingredients

Whisk together the granulated sugar, flour, and salt in a large bowl. For the smoothest filling possible, consider sifting these ingredients so no lumps sneak into your batter.

Step 3: Prepare the Eggs

In another large bowl, whisk the eggs and egg yolk until completely combined and uniform in color. This step ensures your custard base mixes together smoothly.

Step 4: Mix Dry Ingredients Into Eggs

Gradually add the dry mixture to the eggs, whisking continuously. Keep going until your batter is silky smooth and perfectly lump-free, setting the stage for that divine texture.

Step 5: Add the Butter and Extracts

Whisk in the melted butter, vanilla, lemon, and coconut extracts until everything is fully incorporated. This flavorful blend is what makes your Rich & Creamy Buttermilk Pie Recipe stand out from the crowd.

Step 6: Stir in the Warm Buttermilk

Slowly add the warm buttermilk to your mixture, gently stirring until the batter is smooth and free of streaks. If you notice bubbles forming on the surface, let the mixture rest for a minute before moving on.

Step 7: Pour Into Pie Shell

Carefully pour the luscious filling into your chilled, unbaked pie shell, making sure to distribute it evenly. This step sets the foundation for an even bake.

Step 8: Bake the Pie

Start on the lower oven rack and bake for 25 minutes. Then shift the pie to the middle rack and bake another 25 minutes or until the edges are set with a slightly wobbly center. This technique helps the pie cook evenly and develop a tender custard.

Step 9: Cool the Pie

Remove your pie and place it on a cooling rack. Let it cool for 2 to 3 hours until the bottom is no longer hot, allowing the filling to set and firm up beautifully.

Step 10: Chill for Final Set

To achieve that perfect sliceable texture, refrigerate the pie for at least 2 hours. This final chilling step transforms the filling into a creamy, luscious wonder.

Step 11: Serve and Enjoy

Whether you prefer it chilled or at room temperature, this pie shines plain or dressed up with a dollop of whipped cream and fresh berries for a delightful, elegant finish.

How to Serve Rich & Creamy Buttermilk Pie Recipe

Garnishes

A little goes a long way when it comes to garnishes. A whipped cream topping brightens the richness, while fresh berries add bursts of color and a natural tartness that contrast delightfully with the creamy filling. Toasted coconut flakes make an excellent final touch, emphasizing that subtle coconut note in the pie.

Side Dishes

Serve this pie alongside light, fresh accompaniments like a crisp green salad or a refreshing sorbet between bites. These pairings balance the richness perfectly, keeping your palate excited and ready for another forkful of the luscious Rich & Creamy Buttermilk Pie Recipe.

Creative Ways to Present

Why not impress guests by serving mini versions in individual tart pans? You could also present slices on pretty dessert plates with a drizzle of homemade berry coulis or a sprinkle of powdered sugar for added flair. This pie effortlessly adapts whether you want a rustic, homey feel or a polished, elegant dessert.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

After enjoying your pie, store any leftovers in the refrigerator, covered tightly with plastic wrap or foil. It will keep its creamy texture and fresh flavor for up to 3 days, making it perfect for savoring over several sittings.

Freezing

Rich & creamy buttermilk pie does freeze well if you want to prepare it ahead of time. Wrap the pie securely in plastic wrap and then a layer of foil before freezing. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator when ready to enjoy, and avoid freezing if you plan to add whipped cream toppings until serving.

Reheating

This pie is best enjoyed cold or at room temperature. If you prefer it warmed, gently heat individual slices in the microwave for about 10-15 seconds, but be mindful not to overheat as the filling can become too soft or separate.

FAQs

Can I use regular milk instead of buttermilk?

For this Rich & Creamy Buttermilk Pie Recipe, buttermilk is key because it adds the characteristic tang and helps stabilize the texture. Regular milk won’t give you the same flavor or texture, but if needed, you can create a buttermilk substitute by adding a tablespoon of lemon juice or vinegar to a cup of milk and letting it sit for 5 minutes.

Why does my pie crack on top?

Cracking usually happens if the oven is too hot or if the pie is overbaked. Following the baking steps carefully and checking for slight jiggle in the center will help avoid cracks while maintaining that creamy texture.

Can I make this pie gluten-free?

Absolutely! Substitute the all-purpose flour with a gluten-free flour blend that measures cup-for-cup. Just make sure your pie crust is also gluten-free to keep everything consistent.

How do I know when the pie is done?

Look for set edges and a center that’s only slightly jiggly. The pie will continue to set as it cools, so it’s better to err on underbaking slightly than overbaking.

Is it necessary to chill the pie before serving?

Yes, chilling for at least 2 hours gives the filling time to firm up, making slicing cleaner and enhancing the creaminess that makes this pie so special.

Final Thoughts

This Rich & Creamy Buttermilk Pie Recipe is one of those magical desserts that feels both nostalgic and fresh, bringing smiles with every creamy, tangy bite. It’s surprisingly simple to make but delivers a wow factor that never fails to impress. So gather your ingredients, give it a try, and get ready to enjoy a slice of Southern comfort that will soon become a beloved staple in your dessert rotation.

Print